Pages

Monday, 17 March 2014

My take on Policy Exchange's Ofsted report



First thoughts

This is one of the best think-tank reports I've read in a very long time. It's timely, pragmatic, while not being too safe. It's also well written (rarer than you might think).

And importantly it's the first report I've seen that makes real use of social media expertise. The authors acknowledge that they've built on the ideas emerging from twitter and the blogosphere and the final product is much stronger as a result:

"We would like to thank all the teachers and other educationalists who have continued to debate the role of Ofsted on blogs and on Twitter and in doing so, influenced our work - even if they didn’t know they were! Social media is a democratic phenomenon which offers a tremendous opportunity for closing the gap between practitioners and policymakers. If ideas are good and arguments are compelling, then it has never been as easy as now to shape what politicians and policymakers are thinking."

How I wish that social media had been in full flow when I was running the Policy Exchange education department back in 2008 - it would have significantly improved my thinking.

The full report is: here.


The key recommendations

The report sets our a new design for inspections with a shift to regular short inspections based primarily on data and self-evaluation. Only schools where inspectors had concerns (or couldn't tell) would get a longer "tailored inspection". This seems eminently sensible and is line with Ofsted's slow shift towards risk-based assessment over the past decade. 

There would be no teacher observations in these short inspections. Again I strongly agree. And set out my reasons why this would be an important shift here.

Longer tailored inspections would include teacher observations - but inspectors engaged in these visits would have to be trained to a high standard. This feels like a bit of a fudge. Obviously if we are going to have observations then inspectors must be trained but there's no reason given for why they are necessary.

The problem is that even with the best training available observations are not hugely reliable. The report acknowledges that the gold standard models of observation can achieve 61% agreement between 1st and 2nd observers (p.19). That still an awful lot of teachers getting the wrong grade for their teaching - with potentially significant knock on effects for their career. And to achieve that 61% could require up to six separate observations by different people (p.20) which is phenomenally time consuming and expensive.

Of course inspectors, as part of a longer visit, would want to spend time in classrooms but there would need to a really clear added value to formalising these observations to justify the cost both of resources and to individuals.

I remain of the view that the purpose of even a longer inspection should be to understand whether senior and middle leaders understand their school and not to make potentially invalid judgements about individuals' teaching. As I've said previously:

"Inspections should focus on systems. Essentially Ofsted should be looking at what the school is doing to ensure consistent good teaching. They should be inspecting the school's quality assurance not trying to do the quality assurance themselves. In their classroom visits they should be checking the leadership know their teachers and understand how best to support their future development. They should be checking that they have thought about professional development and about performance management. They should be seeing if the behaviour policy is being enforced; and if the school curriculum is actually being used."


Other recommendations

The full list of recommendations can be found in this blog by Joe Kirby. I agree with nearly all of them - particularly a new requirement that inspectors take a data interpretation test and the suggestion that Ofsted end the practice of having thousands of part-time, contracted, additional inspectors.

I have an issue with the suggestion that schools should only be considered outstanding if they "engage in a serious and meaningful way in some form of school to school improvement with other schools - as chosen by the school itself". This is laudable but very hard to inspect without visiting the other schools adding cost and complexity. It could also lead to quite a lot of fake collaboration. I'd rather have an additional category of "system leader" for those schools that were indisputably playing that role.

I also remain unconvinced that we need a separate system for inspecting academy chains. Ofsted are already doing inspections of multiple schools within a chain - which led directly to the recent reduction in the number of schools run by EACT. It's not clear what another framework would add.


Will any of it happen?

There's no question Ofsted have woken up - in recent months - to the extent of the public relations challenge they have. The social media engagement of their Director of Schools Mike Cladingbowl has been welcome and extremely encouraging. The reforms he has proposed in recent months fit with the direction of travel of the Policy Exchange report - shorter more risk-based assessments, emphasising that individual teachers shouldn't be graded - but they are much less radical.

Under the current regime I suspect this will continue - with incremental shifts in the right direction but no big bang reset. Whether we see the Policy Exchange recommendations implemented in full (or even the end of lesson observations all together) will probably depend on who gets to choose the next Chief Inspector and who that is.

  








37 comments:

  1. Great post. Its very interesting and enjoyable. Its must be helpful for us. Thanks for sharing your nice post.
    disable people

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, Excellent post. This article is really very interesting and effective. I think its must be helpful for us. Thanks for sharing your informative.
    mentalist

    ReplyDelete
  3. Since 2004, Shopintimates has become one of the largest Adult Sex Toys Sex Toys
    online and retail shop in Singapore with more than 1500 sex toy products.
    We are a legitimate online shop for shoppers who prefer to shop online
    and we also have a retail showroom located at Bukit
    Timah Shopping Centre for

    shoppers who are more inquisitive and less afraid of walking into a sex toy shop.
    All Sex Toy products are imported from the USA, Germany,
    Canada, Sweden and Japan.We have a wide range of sexual enhancement toys such as condom, lubricant,
    dildo, vibrator, masturbator, fleshlight, tenga,
    we vibe, lelo, fun factory, lingerie and many more.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Johnson laser level spirit levels, construction jobsite measuring tools and marking ... electricians and every day use for homeowners trust Johnson Level Quality.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Bike Pumps are one of those accessories that you'll just need. FREE SHIPPING $49+, Best Selection and Brands with Lifetime Guarantee & Low Price Promise.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Marie We aim to be the premiere Seattle moving company! With our great customer service and the excellent seattle movers, you can trust us to meet all of your Seattle moving needs!

    ReplyDelete
  7. pretup avisPretup mon avis après ce test : clair et sans chichis..

    ReplyDelete


  8. شركة تنظيف منازل بجدة بالبخار شركة تنظيف منازل بجدة


    شركة غسيل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة شركة غسيل خزانات بالمدينة المنورة
    افضل شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة المنورة شركة تنظيف منازل بالمدينة المنورة

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is one of the best post i have read in months, its really great and inspiring, i will really like to read more form you and will like to share with others as well, keep writing more
    Buy Weed Seeds Online
    Buy A-796,260 Online
    Buy Phenethylamine Psychedelics online
    Subutex 8mg Online
    Order Quaaludes Mandrax 300mg online
    Buy DMT Dimethyltryptamine Online
    Valium Diazepam For Sale Online
    Buy Harvoni ledipasvir sofosbuvir online
    Wockhardt Actavis Codeine Online
    Cannabis Oil For Sale
    Buy enzodiazepines online you can as well Whatsapp/Text +1(646)883-3072 , Telegram: primenature or email:primepharma0@gmail.com for more details.

    ReplyDelete
  10. hepsibahis Yüksek bahis oranları sunan en güncel canlı bahis şirketi olan hepsibahis firmasına buradan direk giriş yapın. Youwin adı ile tanınan ve Türkiye deki ismi hepsi bahis olarak kullanılan iddaa firması ile ilgili detaylı bilgileri öğrenin.

    ReplyDelete
  11. bahis siteleri Avrupa da yasal olarak faaliyet gösteren bir çok güvenilir bahis sitesi için güncel giriş adresleri Bahis5XL sitemizde. Bahis5XL.com ile bir çok yabancı bahis şirketi hakkında tanıtım yazılarını inceleyerek, size uygun en iyi iddaa sitesini seçebilirsiniz. Canlı bahis siteleri için en çok bedava deneme bonusu veren Kıbrıs ve Malta lisanslı Türkçe bahis sitelerini Bahis5XL ile inceleyin. Türkiye nin en güncel 2020 bahis siteleri listesi burada.

    ReplyDelete
  12. https://tr.tradefantasyfootball.com/ 1xbet Türkiye, online bahis şirketi hakkında giriş ve inceleme bilgileri. Onebahis firması için 2020 güncel yeni giriş adresi, ödemeler ve üyelik işlemleri için detaylı bilgiler, 1xbahis sayfamızda yer almakta.

    ReplyDelete
  13. meal kits Making cooking a little easier. It's hard, it takes time and who's got the time after a long day of work, looking after kids and being on your feet all day ? I bet you don't and neither do I.. making cheap and tasty modern day meal kits the new normal among all the changes going on in our world today.

    ReplyDelete
  14. less than one dollar web hosting Domain hosting can be hit and miss when it comes to finding it cheap. Don’t get me wrong there are cheap web hosting options, but how about “super cheap and affordable” web hosting. Less than a dollar is “truly” affordable web hosting and this is a chance to get access to web hosting that is consistent and reliable when it comes to affordable web hosting.

    ReplyDelete
  15. https://directoryofangels.com Playing sports and having sex is very much likened. The only thing I have likened is that, over time, they will both last longer. You know the fatigue from that rawness in the early days. You get tired immediately because you haven’t played sports for a long time. Your breath runs out in a very short time. After a while, you start to get used to it. The same thing exists in sex. You cannot share very long-term relationships with your partner. Over time, you train yourself and your body on this subject. Apart from that, it has no direct relationship with sports. We notice this change when I do not meet men for one night in my bed. In particular, I see more clearly with men I have sex at least once a week. They also know that they have seen a rapid recovery. I’m not talking about bodily improvement alone. In addition, of course, his skills in sex are also developing. It’s really important to know how to use this 15 to 20-centimeter piece of meat. Men They see this in my call girl rate in Goa services. They also start learning. They discover how much they can change on a woman.

    ReplyDelete

  16. safe diet pills Authentic Option LLC offers collection of natural herbal products for skincare, hair care, and weight loss. We specialize in thermal weight loss, electrostimulation for muscle toning, cellulite removal, under-eye bags treatment and skincare products. We have an amazing range of beard growing products.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Facts substance abuse Addiction stands as the top public health problem in America outstanding all other major diseases including stroke, heart diseases and even cancer. The population of addicts is far larger than the patients suffering from the three mentioned diseases in America with sufferers ranging in millions.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Crunchyroll Crunchyroll is a dedicated anime streaming service that uploads over 30,000 episodes of top-rated anime episodes to subscribe members to it. Crunchyroll offers a comprehensive selection of high-quality dubbed anime series available for viewing no matter what time of day or night. All users can enjoy streaming live anime trailers, latest episodes, and popular anime show in the Crunchyroll catalog.

    ReplyDelete
  19. schlüsseldienst münster Wir sind Ihr günstiger Schlüsseldienst in Ihrer Nähe – wir helfen Ihnen in nur 15 Minuten! Es ist unser Bestreben notbedürftigen Kunden innerhalb kurzer Zeit aus ihrer missglückten Situation zu helfen – und das dabei serviceorientiert, zuverlässig und günstig.

    ReplyDelete
  20. legit online gambling sites Compare the best legit online casinos that pay real money including the best crypto casinos, best mobile casinos and the best online casinos in 2021

    ReplyDelete
  21. Why struggle to finish your Literature assignments while you can get Literature Review Assignment Help from our professional writers? You can also order for Literature Review Writing Services from our Best writers. You can also purchase Pre-written Research Papers that will exceed your expectation.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Why do we need a driver's license? Authentic Legal Driver's License Online | Driver's license for sale.

    The driving license is an important and vital document in the life of every adult, it must be produced and delivered with a certain regularity and legality so that it does not endanger the user and those around him. Do you need this very important document, but you don't know how? Do you want to improve your driving license? Has your driving license been suspended for drug or alcohol use? Contact ( obtenerlalicenciadeconducir@gmail.com ) (whatsapp +33 6 44 63 31 60) to facilitate the purchase of a new driving license. Safe and reliable services are guaranteed.

    https://www.obterumacarteirademotorista.com/contate-nos
    https://patentediguidaoriginaleonline.com/
    https://obtenerlalicenciadeconducir.com/contanos/
    https://obtenerlalicenciadeconducir.com/testimonios/
    https://obtenerlalicenciadeconducir.com/sobre-nosotros/
    https://obtenerlalicenciadeconducir.com/servicios/
    https://www.obterumacarteirademotorista.com/sobre-n-s
    https://obtenerlalicenciadeconducir.com/

    Do i need a driving license to buy a carexchange eu driving license to uk online |buy real registered eu drivers license |instant eu license: buy real registered eu drivers license buy driving license| driver license germany |how to buy a car with no drivers license|buy a driving license |buy eu driver's licenses online |kaufen sie einen echten registrierten führerschein |buy registered german driving license |buy real registered eu drivers license without testing |kaufen sie einen echten deutschen führerschein online| real drivers license for sale online |buy real registered eu drivers license |instant eu license: buy real registered eu drivers license buy driving license| driver license germany |buy registered drivers license |real drivers license for sale online |buy registered drivers license |order novelty drivers license for sale online |order novelty drivers license for sale online |buy a car without drivers license| buy a driver license online|

    ReplyDelete
  23. motherhood CO.MOM is a fun new online magazine and social network community created by moms for moms. Read interesting articles, get advice from our agony aunt, aunt\y anne, learn how to earn an income online with our guru debbie or you can even seek medical advice from our resident physician dr samantha and relax while checking out the latest horoscopes from our trained mystic. Theres even a thriving forum community where moms of the world can get together and enjoy good conversation along with lots of other fun ways to kill some time with a cuppa when taking a break from being super mom at co.mom.

    ReplyDelete
  24. polyuria As a worldwide leader in industrial coatings and spray-on truck bed liners, ArmorThane offers a full line of top-quality polyurethane and polyurea coatings and high-tech spraying equipment and supplies. Our professionally applied pure and hybrid polyurethane and polyurea formulas are extremely durable, flexible and safe.

    ReplyDelete
  25. polyurea As a worldwide leader in industrial coatings and spray-on truck bed liners, ArmorThane offers a full line of top-quality polyurethane and polyurea coatings and high-tech spraying equipment and supplies. Our professionally applied pure and hybrid polyurethane and polyurea formulas are extremely durable, flexible and safe.

    ReplyDelete