Friday, 27 September 2013

Why I changed my mind on for-profit schools

Back before the last election I wrote several reports arguing in favour of profit-making schools.

In 2009 I wrote:
"The question of profit is one the most emotive aspects of [school reform] and has been the focus of discontent on the left of American and Swedish politics. There seems to be little basis for this, or for the queasiness over potential profit-making schools in the UK, beyond an intuitive dislike of the idea that money could be made from educating children."
I never thought it was key to reform
"We do not believe that the inclusion of for profit firms in any reform is essential to making
making reform work – and reformers may consider the additional opposition it creates not worth the trouble."
But I did think that it would create extra incentives for people to develop federations of schools (which I've always thought is key to the success of any school reform movement):
"However, for-profit groups are much more likely to have the scale and ambition necessary to create multi-school federations. Larger charities with a national or regional focus, such as Harris and ARK in the UK or KIPP and the other CMOs in the US, are also able to do this, but such groups are relatively few and far between, especially during an economic downturn."

So why have I changed my mind?

Well I haven't had a Damascene conversion to Marxism. I still think that the intuitive horror many on the left have to the use of for-profit companies to provide public services is irrational. There are plenty of existing examples where for-profit companies fulfil a need at least as well as alternatives. It perhaps works best where services are simple and easy to measure (rubbish collection; maintenance etc...) but the NHS uses for-profit companies to buy-in treatments; many parents spend their nursery entitlement in for-profit nurseries. And so on. In parts of the developing world for-profit schools are the only chance many children get to have a decent education.

The question for me isn't "are for-profit schools inherently good or bad" it's "would for-profit schools improve the education system as it currently is". And there my answer is no - for three connected reasons.

One: the incentives that I thought allowing profit would create exist anyway

I failed to predict, back in 2009, how many natural entrepreneurs existed in the education system who would take advantage of the Academies Act to quickly develop chains and federations. When I left the DfE back in February there were around 150 schools that had not only converted to academy status but started up their own federation. I expect that number is now closer to 200. Some chains have grown very fast (some have grown too fast).

In some cases I guess this surge of entrepreneurship is linked to desire for personal gain or status (you don't have to run a for-profit company to make a lot of money yourself). But I think in most cases it has been motivated by moral purpose - successful school leaders wanting to reach more children than they could do by running a single school.

Two: allowing for-profit wouldn't in any case create much extra incentive because it's not a profitable industry

As many a CEO has found to their cost in America and Sweden it's very hard to make any money out of running schools. 80% of a school's costs are staff; without good staff you can't have a good school so offering lower salaries isn't really an option. There are only two ways you can make any money. First employ fewer teachers by using blended learning approaches. To put in kindly there's not a huge amount of evidence for these approaches (the for-profit "virtual" charter school sector in the US is an absolute scandal). Secondly, run so many schools that you make your money by cutting back-office costs. But the number of schools you'd need to make much profit make this pretty undesirable too. Most of the reputable firms that have run the numbers on schools have backed off pretty quickly.

You might be thinking (though you probably aren't) that it's worth a try anyway. You might get some really innovative companies that come up with a way of running great schools and making some money at the same time. But...

Three: allowing for-profit would require a complete overhaul of current processes
One of the big misconceptions about the Government's reform programme is that it "paves the way" for profit-making schools. In fact the system only works because all academies and free schools are not-for-profit. Back under the last Government anti-academy campaigners judicially reviewed the decision to allow UCL to sponsor an academy in Camden. They argued that it broke EU law because there wasn't a public procurement process where anyone could bid for the "contract". The judge ruled for the Government but only on the grounds that academies were all sponsored by not-for-profits. Had the Government handed that academy to SERCO they would have lost the review.

That means if the current Government wanted to allow for-profits they'd have to run a full procurement exercise for every sponsored academy and free school. The Swedes get around this by giving licenses to run free schools to any provider who meets a certain threshold. But that means losing any real control over who can set up a school. And as it precludes handing out capital (because you don't know how many will be over the threshold) it also pushes not-for-profits out of the market. There are no big not-for-profit chains like ARK or KIPP in Sweden. In any case that model wouldn't work for sponsored academies.

So that's why I changed my mind. We don't need them and the cost of overhauling the system is completely disproportionate to any potential benefit they could bring. For these reasons I can't see any Government going down this route for the foreseeable future.






  1. Here's another reason why pursuing for profit education is a bad idea:

    because it distracts so much time, attention and energy away from the many powerful and positive reforms which web2.0 technology has made so easy to achieve.

    This isn't really just about for profit education is it though Sam? The comments you've made apply equally well to the whole debacle of the pursuit of the idea that a totally free 'market' in education is affordable and beneficial.

    1. It is an extra activity of writing skills in school to develop reforms to be little basis of getting Education success. Dissertation Help Service UK at cheap price and affordable.

    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. re sams quote "In some cases I guess this surge of entrepreneurship is linked to desire for personal gain or status (you don't have to run a for-profit company to make a lot of money yourself)"

    As an example of the above I would cite TeachFirst which look after their executives and staff very nicely thank you at a cost of , I believe £38 k per teacher trained. I believe there's a 50% drop out rate so this would price the cost of Teach First providing a teacher lasting longer than 3 years as £76K.

    It's about time a "value for money" review was perhaps undertaken agaisnt other teacher training institutions.

  3. it's very valuable info. thanks

  4. BigProfitbuzz is an Indian stock market advisory firm. BigProfitbuzz proven month after month that trading and investing in stock market can be profitable whether market is bull or bearMCX, STOCK TIPS The NIFTY is showing a very strong buy side but it will be very risky to buy on a higher level due to high stoploss. So we suggest all the traders to make a buy position in NIFTY around 6600-6700 with stoploss of 6500 for the target of 6900-7000.This will be the best strategy for this kind of market. Traders can also make a buy in NIFTY 50 stocks according to the NIFTY levels. We believe in less call but good call. For further update you can visit our website. You can also fill our two days trial form on our website to check the accuracy of our calls.

  5. Nice blog and so informative thank you for sharing us.
    Free Gold Mcx Tips

  6. That's really very interesting plus informative article, I am impressed with your effort.
    Thanks for sharing
    Professional Assignment Writing Service

  7. While much has been written on this topic, your article expresses both the good and bad aspects of this important topic, Sam Freedman (@samfr), I must Thank you for your thorough research and clear writing.
    Buy Assignment Writing Help Online

  8. Sam Freedman, You shared informative post, I just like this post because it is well written and informative
    Need Help with Writing Assignment

  9. Hay Guys Are you searching a any option to make money from online? This is for you also. Visit here at once. And start make money at your home. Just make extra cash.
    ways to make money

  10. Sharing personal opinions and experiences through blog writing is really a good approach… Thank you for placing such a good post and sharing your opinions and experiences with us…Nursing Essay Writing Service UK

  11. Thanks for your excellent posting. I really enjoyed reading this blog
    Nursing Essay Writing Service UK

  12. Huge numbers of us find that there are more than a few undesirable assignments in our scholarly lifetimes. Whether in High School or a school English course, the one thing to recollect is that you never need to peruse something that you would prefer not proposal format

  13. We are rather of the firm opinion and the view now and the probable opinion would surely amount to better understanding of various concerns. management personal statement

  14. You share a good blog and many people get information from your blog.

    Nursing Dissertation Help

  15. You shared informative post, I just like this post because it is well written and informative
    UK Assignment Writing Services

  16. IPL live 2017 Useful and well written post. Thanks for the share. Continue your good work

  17. Such a nice blog and i appreciate your all efforts about your thoughts. it's really good work. well done. I would like to share something really helpful for education. Write My Assignment Malaysia

  18. Congrats on having such well managed site! It has good looks and contains informative content as well. We are also a web portal where students get the help with the academic writing by opting for our assignment help online and can get a well written assignment.
    Assignment writing

  19. Assignment Help UKservices provided by are among the premier Assignment Help Australia help services offered online. Assignment Help Australia service has helped thousands of students achieve high scores providing them with right time to manage hectic work schedules. Assignment Help Australia by ensures that all Assignment Help Australia help requirement meets the rigorous criteria of distinction grade. Nursing Assignment helpservices is a tough task to provide. The writing services require in depth knowledge of all basic subjects required for application in nursing practice. Nursing is an art and a science as well and combined together they provide the right patient care.

  20. I am an antique article collector and this article is one of the best I have ever read. I hope to see the same amazing work from you in future. Thanks Assignment help | Need Assignment help | Marketing Assignment help | Law Assignment help


  21. Couldn't be written any better. Reading this post reminds me of my old roommate! He always kept talking about this Assignment help| Need Assignment help

  22. Interesting article! Thank you for sharing them! I hope you will continue to have similar posts to share with everyone. movie leather jacket

  23. With the goal that's the reason I altered my opinion. We needn't bother with them and the cost of redesiging the framework is totally unbalanced to any potential advantage they could bring. Consequently I can't perceive any Government going down this course for years to come. Buy an Essay

  24. This is a very well written post, my compliments. I’m glad to find your post. Keep sharing this type of stuff.
    Get Assignment Help Melbourne from Experienced Writers

  25. Before long obviously this thought was promising and doable, for the most part due to the application advertise being as of now one of the quickest developing markets today. The field of web applications is as of now a substantial market with enormous potential for testing. USA Assignment

  26. The presentation of the Stealth Atom Sling enabled me to flawlessly progress my most loved day by day everything holder, to my angling gear. I was toying with getting a midriff pack, yet to me the sling just bodes well in all angling applications; particularly, on the grounds that it doesn't ride sufficiently low on the body to get wet when you are swim angling in profound water. Do my Research Paper USA

  27. There's in no way like a blockbuster motion picture to transport you to a different universe. Yet, the dream doesn't need to end when the motion picture does. The stuff that you watch may really be the springing board for a decent blog thought. Assignment Service